Tags
Island Life, Word Birds & Process.
It had to happen. Even Maggie O’Farrell has been the recipient of the death-star review. And a quick search also throws up the likes of Louise Beech & Amanda Jennings. (I know, how very dare they???) Even the blessed Mrs Woolf doesn’t escape. Twenty-one 1* reviews for Mrs Dalloway!
You kinda know it’s coming. When it does mind, when it’s laced with stupid, it takes you aback.
“One dimensional characters, poorly written. Could have been so much better. I couldn’t wait for it to end.”
Which does of course beg the question, ‘Didn’t you realise you were allowed to stop reading?’ In the spirit of being a good loser, I posted the review on FB. The resulting comments go to show what a lovely gang I hang out with.
“Join the Jane Austen club.”
“Pish & Nonsense.”
“You’ve got to admire the reviewer’s Stoicism. It can’t have been easy… Almost like reading is an activity that happens *to* someone.”
“All hail the one star review. You’ve arrived.”
“Good grief!”
“You aren’t an author until you get a one star review.”
“If I hadn’t read Ghostbird already I would buy it on the “strength” of that review!”
And my particular favourite: “Couldn’t wait for it to end” ???? Don’t read it then you numpty!”
These are just a selection. You get the picture. By close of day, I’d ended up with another lovely review, several promises of reviews, two sales & some of the funniest exchanges I’ve had on FB for weeks. So cheers, whoever you are, poor woman nailed to your chair until the bitter end, you’ve done me a massive favour. I’m in good company; I’m on another list with some of my literary sheroes!
As my daughter said just now, ‘Bloody awful movie last night, Mum, couldn’t wait for it to be over.’
Absolutely brilliant! And actually, I think 1 star says more about the reviewer than the writer!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you very much, Linda. My sentiment exactly. And what larks it’s provided. Or, as my daughter said, tongue in cheek, ‘Is this thread still going? Can’t wait for it to end… ‘ 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
My favorite one star review (Finder) said, ” Too much sex.” I think I got more readers because if that review than any other!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well, you know me on that score: More is Less – but no doubt you are right! xXx
LikeLike
Seriously, I think they must have been reviewing the wrong book, Carol. But well done for taking it in such good part. And that’s a very distinguished club you’ve joined – will put good money on me joining you in the next few months!
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s a rite of passage, cariad!
Thank you kindly. xXx
LikeLiked by 1 person